“We’re Too Big to Be Agile”
"We’re Too Big to Be Agile"—Debunking the Myth
Recently, I was chatting with a former colleague who made a comment I’ve heard all too often:
“We are too big to be agile.”
“We are too big to be agile.”
It’s a common belief, especially in large organizations with complex structures and lots of moving parts. I hear similar refrains like:
- “Only small software companies can be agile.”
- “Our development teams use agile—that’s enough.”
If you dig a little deeper, you’ll find these comments usually come from senior leaders—and they’re often rooted in fear.
The Size Excuse: Why Not?
Steve Denning, in his Forbes article The Irresistible Rise Of Agile: A Paradigm Shift In Management, addresses this head-on. Coming from the World Bank, a massive organization, he understands red tape and bureaucracy better than most. When he investigated high-performing teams, he asked the same question every agile practitioner asks when they hear, “We’re too big”: Why not?
Denning points out that the world’s largest and fastest-growing companies—Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Google, and Microsoft—have all adopted agile management practices. The result? They deliver:
- Instant, frictionless value at scale
- Intimate, incremental, and risk-free innovation
If these giants can do it, why can’t anyone else?
What’s Really Holding Leaders Back?
Despite admiring the success of agile-driven companies, many executives hesitate. Denning found that their skepticism is rooted in two main fears:
- Fear of the Unknown
- Fear of Losing Control
Let’s break those down.
Fear of Losing Control
Much of this fear comes from the concept of self-managed teams. Traditional organizations are built on hierarchy—everyone has a boss, and work flows from the top down. The idea of letting go of that control is unsettling for many managers.
Even in companies with “agile teams,” it’s common for team members to report to different managers, creating silos and roadblocks. Imagine a hockey or basketball team where each player listens only to their personal coach and ignores teammates in need. It’s unthinkable in sports, and it shouldn’t happen in business, either. Agile teams thrive on collaboration, mutual support, and shared goals.
Leaders need to realize that empowering teams to self-manage doesn’t mean abdicating responsibility. Instead, it frees leaders to focus on strategy and vision, while building trust and stronger leadership skills. Servant leadership—guiding from behind and without authority—fosters real teamwork and innovation.
Fear of the Unknown
Many managers see agile as chaotic—no rules, just a rush to get things done. But that’s a misconception. True agility is highly disciplined. It’s about clear goals, strong teamwork, and constant learning. As Jeff Sutherland describes in “The Art of Doing Twice the Work in Half the Time,” agile isn’t about chaos—it’s about focus, ownership, and results.
Agile at Scale: It’s Possible
Jeff Dalton, in his interviews and writings, emphasizes that any organization can become agile with the right leadership mindset. It’s about learning, adapting, and embracing change at every level—not just within development teams.
When leaders make this shift, the benefits are clear:
- Employees feel a sense of ownership and pride in their work
- Teams collaborate more effectively
- Clients receive better products and services, faster
Bottom line:
Size isn’t a barrier to agility; mindset is. The world’s biggest and most successful companies have proven that agile works at scale. The real challenge is letting go of old habits and embracing the discipline, trust, and collaboration that true agility requires.
Size isn’t a barrier to agility; mindset is. The world’s biggest and most successful companies have proven that agile works at scale. The real challenge is letting go of old habits and embracing the discipline, trust, and collaboration that true agility requires.
Ready to explore how your large organization can become truly agile?
Let’s connect and discuss practical steps to start your agile journey. Book a call
Let’s connect and discuss practical steps to start your agile journey. Book a call
"I help create ecosystems that become legacies.”
- Jeremy Berriault
Quick Links
Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday
9 am to 5 pm
Saturday - Sunday
Closed